|December 07, 2022 Follow us|
A taste of Chicago, 2013-style
Elyse Glickman finds Chicago very much a food lovers’ paradise, with sumptuous steaks, hearty farm-to-table fare, dressed-up hot dogs and deep-dish pizzas
In the late 1970s, The Taste of Chicago—mother of all American summer food-and-entertainment festivals—did much more than create a template for foodie celebrations worldwide. It also sparked a transformation that took the city from a beer, hot dog and pizza town into an innovative restaurant capital. Granted, people from around the world seek out Vienna beef hot dogs and deep-dish pizza—and for good reason. Today, however, classic steakhouses are running neck and neck with high-concept restaurants that defy genres.
If you find yourself in “Chicagoland” any time of year, be sure to find time to eat your way around the city, both at hidden neighbourhood gems and classy destination spots. Here’s just a tiny taste of the best.
Although many a local reviewer and Playboy dubbed Keefer’s one of the best steakhouses in America, and the chops (including the Delmonico filet that’s much in demand at lunch and dinner) live up to the hype, owner Rich Keefer winces slightly and will tell you the fish dishes created by chef John Hogan are incredible as well. Given that he and his brother conceived the airy, Frank Lloyd Wright-esque restaurant, he ought to know. And yes, the fish dishes are incredible. The dinner preparation of the halibut, in fact, meets all the requirements of what a restaurant’s signature dish ought to be (Dijon mustard, brioche breadcrumbs, wild mushroom sauce and watercress coulis). If you come for lunch, you have the added benefit of some fun extras such as a bowl of seasonally tuned soup of the day and fluffy potato croquettes. Salads, meanwhile, are crisp, clean and spare on dressing, which is great considering that the mix of vegetables are what will sell them. The broccoli salad is a surprising mix of broccoli heads, apple, fennel and podda cheese, while their basic artisan tomato salad is punched up with the addition of pine nuts. If you’re a chocolate fan, meanwhile, you’ll be quite happy with the orange-chocolate crème brûlée or the thin-but-dense triple chocolate cake adorned with honey chocolate ice cream.
While the bar offers a mix of traditional and modern cocktails, the 160-set main dining area features a full menu that capitalizes on Walton’s now-famous herb and vegetable rooftop garden (no small feat as Chicago’s seasons are well defined and very intense in terms of climate). With regards to the restaurant’s signature offerings, Markethouse is a true “meat and potatoes” kind of venue, right down to its dense, herby meatloaf along with other simply plated meats, poultry and fish (much of it sourced by Slagel Family Farms in Fairbury, Ill.). The mac and cheese and risotto are also exceptional—no truffle oil or gourmet pretense, just melt-in-your-mouth perfection. Other nice touches include extras with a story behind them, including a small jug of pickled vegetables and sweet potato bread from the local bakery Red Hen.
Desserts, however, are where Walton’s crew ups the ante. The butterscotch bread pudding is dense, substantial and nuanced. Key lime pie has a herbaceous savoury hit from the Thai basil in the chef’s garden.
Though Prairie Grass does have some elements of Chicago steakhouse and Greek family restaurant, don’t pin it into a genre. That’s the vision devised by James Beard award-winning chef and Evanston native Stegner and colleague Bumbaris, who set out to bring luxury culinary touches (they originally teamed up at the Ritz–Carlton Chicago) to home-spun Midwestern fare. There is also a farm-to-table element to their pitch, but the presentation and execution of the dishes is what makes this spot so strong.
The moussaka, for example, comes in its own skillet and replaces the ground beef with a savoury mint creek farm lamb with short rib texture. The widely acclaimed Chicago Magazine’s number-one sirloin burger (that’s a mouthful!) replaces a bun and greasy fries with a thin crust of mild Amish Bleu cheese topping and crisp baked potato wedges. Rather than heavy tartare sauce, the Maine peeky-toe crab cake is adorned with a cucumber, avocado and grapefruit salad. Another element that has made the restaurant a “top story” among local and visiting diners is the fact that several popular menu items feature meats and honey from a farm owned by noted Chicago journalist and TV presenter Bill Kurtis. He put an extra personal stamp on the venue by donating the large-screen televisions for the bustling sports bar area. Even an hour out of the downtown Loop, you can’t get more “Chicago” than that!
The global fashion magazine
Elyse Glickman is US west coast editor of Lucire.
Order a print copy
Download the Ipad app
Download the Android app
Download the PDF edition
Watch Lucire TV
Lucire on Instagram
Lucire on Dailymotion
Lucire on Twitter
Lucire Facebook fan page
Lucire on Mastodon
Lucire on Vkontakte
Selected team Instagram accounts Jack Yan | Sopheak Seng | Elyse Glickman | Stanley Moss | Paula Sweet | Joanne Gair | Lola Cristall | Jody Miller | Jamie Dorman | Summer Rayne Oakes | Doug Rimington | Tanya Sooksombatisatian