LIVING Dolce & Gabbana’s video campaign prior to a Beijing show was labelled as racist, part of a pattern that can be traced back to western imperalism
From the January 2019 issue of Lucire KSA
Main photograph by WiNG/Creative Commons
In November, Dolce & Gabbana found itself at the centre of a controversy as it previewed a Beijing catwalk show. One of the three videos featured a Chinese model attempting to eat an Italian meal, with Mandarin narration, but poked fun at the cultures: the model looked stereotypical, one segment asked if a piece of cannoli was too big for her, and the subtitles referred to chopsticks as a ‘small-stick’ while referring to Italian food as great—the sort of juxtaposition that had Chinese audiences insulted, its culture infantilized; at best, they felt the promotion was in extremely poor taste.
D&G deleted the campaign from its Weibo social media account shortly after, but a boycott movement began in China, with major Chinese e-tail sites JD.com and Tmall (owned by Chinese giant Alibaba, itself worth over US$500,000 million) pulling all Dolce & Gabbana products. Lane Crawford, one of Hong Kong’s most storied retailers, announcing that they would no longer stock D&G. Net-a-Porter and Secoo pulled D&G products from their Chinese sites. Models scheduled to walk in the show declined, distancing themselves from the label.
It wasn’t the first time D&G found itself afoul of Chinese culture: for its spring 2016 collection, it sent down Asian models in stereotypical Chinese-inspired outfits (though this passed without many raised eyebrows); and in April 2017, its D&G Loves China campaign showed models mingling with locals—but only portrayed them at locations that painted China as backwards, and Chinese people as impoverished, fuelling an old “Bamboo Curtain” stereotype. Again, D&G was forced to delete the images from its Weibo.
Dolce & Gabbana was compelled to cancel its Beijing show, although the video wasn’t the only thing that had Chinese audiences up in arms. A day after the controversy exploded in China, Diet Prada posted racist Instagram private messages reportedly from Stefano Gabbana, referring to China using an emoji for excrement, and as a ‘Dirty Smelling Mafia’; the company later claimed Gabbana’s account has been ‘hacked’ (more than a few disbelieved this), and that they ‘have nothing but respect for China and the people of China,’ though they stayed silent on the original video.
After six days, Domenico Dolce and Stefano Gabbana released a video apologizing for the first video. (There was a greater delay, of eight days, in 2012, after a security guard forbade a local from taking a photo of its storefront in Hong Kong, leading to protests.)
The latest case was damaging enough for Dolce & Gabbana, for whom 30 per cent of sales come from the Asia–Pacific.
The apologies may fall on deaf ears as Chinese customers are unlikely to forget, and with major retailers no longer stocking the brand, D&G may have found itself irreparably harmed.
One writer, Xiang Kai, of Shanghai, set fire to over US$20,000 worth of his Dolce & Gabbana products, in protest. He shared a photo online, with the caption: ‘Some people say you’ve wasted a lot of money. I’m willing to waste this money for the nation’s dignity.’
Dolce & Gabbana had found itself in hot water with other cultures, too, sending down blackamoor earrings for its spring 2013 collection (leading to accusations of cultural appropriation), and calling a shoe the ‘Slave Sandal’ in 2016.
China, as the world’s second-largest economy by GDP, with an extremely large online population, is no longer the sort of country that takes racism lying down, especially, too, as many of its own companies and brands rival, and even beat, western ones at their own game, something unthinkable by some 20 years ago.
The controversy, as Lucire fashion and beauty editor Sopheak Seng notes, makes you wonder if race and fashion can sit side by side in the modern climate.
He cites an October 2018 example featuring Kendall Jenner, who had a Edwardian- and Gibson Girl-inspired hair style for a Vogue photo shoot. A second inspiration was the big hair of the 1960s and 1970s. However, many commented that the ’do looked like an afro, that the shoot culturally appropriated from black Americans, and that a black model should have been used for the shoot. The magazine was forced to issue a statement: ‘We apologize if it came across differently than intended, and we certainly did not mean to offend anyone by it.’
He also notes that Yves Saint Laurent, Tom Ford, Vivienne Westwood and John Galliano (for Dior) have borrowed from the orient and have never been criticized for it, though neither crossed the line by running campaigns that suggested that their own culture was superior to China’s. The Metropolitan Museum of Art’s China: through the Looking Glass exhibition was specifically about how Chinese culture impacted on western fashion. It was respectful in its attempts to deal with what the late Palestinian author Edward Saïd called ‘orientalism’, a western approach that patronizes the east, a hangover from western imperialism from the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries; instead favouring the lens of viewing the orient as authentic.
Meanwhile, Guo Pei, the Chinese fashion designer—and the one who dressed Rihanna in a breathtaking golden gown for the 2015 Met Gala—takes modern couture styles from the occident, but in an uncontroversial way, perhaps showing some universality in how cultures perceive beauty, extravagance, and visual balance.
In the second decade of the twenty-first century, it appears that colonialism continues in some quarters, where the west attempts to justify negative portrayals of Chinese, of Arabs and Muslims, and other cultures through an “us and them” lens, still propagated through literature, and now, through media and social networks. However, as more countries engage in international dialogue, orientalism and other forms of cultural assault are being challenged and reversed, even by westerners themselves who see through it. When borrowing occurs, there is more awareness of other cultures and the pride people have in them, and a greater chance of a dialogue taking place. As Vogue demonstrated, when there is a misunderstanding, an apology goes a long way to quieten any controversy. However, Dolce & Gabbana’s delay in apologizing was a sign that the 33-year-old label had been happy having an enfant terrible image, slow to extinguish the flames—except this time it’s had a real effect on their wallets. In an age when the west looks east for sales, Dolce & Gabbana’s six days are a cautionary tale for those wishing to retail in the Middle East and the Far East. •
View this post on Instagram
Fifteen years and 150 finalists later, the @CFDA/Vogue Fashion Fund prize has created global stars, local heroes, a must-watch New York Fashion Week, and, most important, a true sense of community among designers of all ages and backgrounds—all with differing aesthetic and commercial aspirations—who communicate, collaborate, and essentially care for one another through the fun and not-so-fun times. Laura Vassar Brock—one of the founders of 2016 #CVFF winner Brock Collection—says, “We spoke to a few friends who had gone through it, and they all said the same thing: that the Fashion Fund is a life-changing experience. And indeed it was!” Tap the link in our bio to learn more. Photographed by @mikaeljansson, styled by @tonnegood, Vogue, November 2018
Related articles hand-picked by our editors
The fall of the influencer
Lucire predicted the rise of the social influencer many years ago. But now that such ideas have mainstreamed, we’re less optimistic about their staying power—by Jack Yan and Portia Gascoigne
From issue 38 of Lucire
Awkwafina: working among crazy rich Asians
Rapper and actress Awkwafina plays Peik Lin in the summer hit Crazy Rich Asians. We sit down with her to ask about her experiences on the film, whether she saw any real-life crazy rich Asians, and what it was like working with Constance Wu and director Jon M. Chu
Lucire’s news-makers of 2017
There’s little doubt in our minds that Stella McCartney is a news-maker this year—and joining her are five journalists, three politicians, and an engineer
Order a print copy
Download the Ipad app
Download the Android app
Download the PDF edition
Watch Lucire TV
Lucire on Instagram
Lucire on Dailymotion
Lucire on Twitter
Lucire Facebook fan page
Lucire on Mastodon
Lucire on Vkontakte
Selected team Instagram accounts Jack Yan | Sopheak Seng | Elyse Glickman | Stanley Moss | Paula Sweet | Joanne Gair | Lola Cristall | Jody Miller | Jamie Dorman | Summer Rayne Oakes | Doug Rimington | Tanya Sooksombatisatian